Welcome! Sign in or Join    
Useful Links
Featured Ads
Search this state:
Find Results with:

All Locations: New York > Cayuga Lake Lake Vacation Rentals (9)

map icon
 Bedrooms   Sleeps   Pets   Smoking
 Waterfront       Location from Zip Code
Beach Camp, Priceless Sunsets, And Fishing on Cayuga Lake in New York for rent on

 Beach Camp, Priceless Sunsets, And Fishing
Ad # 13733
Nice Family Lakefront Home On East Side Of Cayuga on Cayuga Lake in New York for rent on

 Nice Family Lakefront Home On East Side Of Cayuga
Ad # 11342
Water's Edge Lakehouse on Cayuga Lake in New York for rent on

 Water's Edge Lakehouse
Ad # 10519
Level Lake Front East Side

 Level Lake Front East Side "daddy's Lake" Vacation Rental
Ad # 8891
Level Beach, Dock, 4 Bed 2 1/2 Bath Oasis on East Side Cayuga Lake in New York for rent on

 Level Beach, Dock, 4 Bed 2 1/2 Bath Oasis
Ad # 7845
East Side Cottage - Lansing on Cayuga in New York for rent on

 East Side Cottage - Lansing
Ad # 6854
Union Springs Ny Vacation Rental, Cayuga Lake, Sunset Cottage #2 on Cayuga Lake in New York for rent on

 Union Springs Ny Vacation Rental, Cayuga Lake, Sunset Cottage #2
Ad # 5209
Union Springs Ny Vacation Rental Sunset Cottage-1 Cayuga Lake on Cayuga Lake in New York for rent on

 Union Springs Ny Vacation Rental Sunset Cottage-1 Cayuga Lake
Ad # 5208
Cayuga Lake Charming Cottage Rental Near Ithaca,  on Cayuga in New York for rent on

 Cayuga Lake Charming Cottage Rental Near Ithaca,
Ad # 3832

Sign up for our AUTO NOTIFY program and receive free updates on new listings that match your search criteria.

If you’re considering lake homes for rent in New York, Cayuga Lake should be a strong contender. Carved out of the land by glaciers thousands of years ago, Cayuga Lake is the longest of the state’s Finger Lakes and is also one of the deepest. The lake is a recreation haven year-round, catering to boaters, hunters, anglers, hikers, and even bird watchers. The surrounding areas are also steeped in culture and creativity, ensuring your Cayuga Lake experience will be engaging and absolutely unforgettable!

Cayuga Lake spans almost 40 miles, ultimately joining the Eerie Canal, and reaches a staggering depth of 435 feet at one point. The complex topography of the lake features mudflats to the north that host various species of migratory birds, along with shallow waters to the south that typically freeze in the winter. This type of intricate ecosystem not only attracts avid bird watchers, but it also makes for some darn good fishing! While northern pike, largemouth bass, smallmouth bass, and pickerel are found in the more shallow waters of the lake, trout fishing is all the rage in these parts. Rainbow, lake, and brown trout are particularly prized catches, but you’re also likely to find perch, pike, and bullhead. With so many worthy opponents waiting just below the surface, your hook is bound to snag on something worth bragging about!

Cayuga Lake is a popular destination for off-road cyclists, avid hikers, and boating aficionados as well. Mile upon mile of unpaved trail wraps around the lake for you to test your bike gears on, while many of the surrounding hiking trails lead directly to spectacular waterfalls. Numerous public and private marinas dot the shoreline of Cayuga Lake for your convenience: launch your sailboat, jet ski, motorboat, or anything that floats and delight in a new perspective of the lake’s majesty. And to think that lake homes for rent can call all of these striking elements part of their landscaping!

With so much to revel in on the lake, it may be tempting to never leave your lake-view property—that is until you realize what lies just off the shoreline. Cayuga Lake is surrounded by several notable golf courses. Some courses, such as King Ferry Golf Club and Seneca Falls Country Club, have breathtaking views of the lake from the course. Rolling hills, deep ponds, and stunning views combine to create a truly original game of golf. If you’d like to live on a Cayuga Lake golf course, visit for property listings and details.

Cayuga Lake touches Ithaca, New York, at its southern tip. Home to prestigious Cornell University and Ithaca College, the town has a bohemian charm that celebrates the area’s unique heritage and culture. The world-class dining scene is supported by locally sourced produce from eco-friendly farms, and the fine cuisine washes down quite nicely with a glass of Cayuga Lake wine. The lake is literally surrounded by award-winning wineries on all sides.

Surround yourself with all Cayuga Lake hast to offer today!

Cayuga Lake is the longest of New York's eleven Finger Lakes, and is located in the heart of the region. Its blue waters reflect hillsides lush with vineyards and orchards, set among forests of maple, oak and hemlock while waterfalls pour in splendid gorges. Charming lakeside villages and towns inspire the relaxation found in a gentler place. Reachable by all major state highways, the area is in central New York, approximately one hour from Syracuse and three hours from Albany and Buffalo.

Spanning from the Montezuma Wildlife Refuge in Cayuga and Seneca Counties to the City of Ithaca in Tompkins County, Cayuga Lake stretches for 38.2 miles. This lake has 95.3 miles of shoreline, 66 square miles of surface area, and a depth of 435 feet. Among other attributes, Cayuga Lake is acclaimed for being part of the original Erie Canal (Cayuga-Seneca Canal), and for being a designated Important Bird Area for waterfowl migrating along the Atlantic Flyway. Each year, thousands of Canadian Geese, Ducks, Loons and other birds enjoy the lake's waters as a rest stop on their way to warmer weather for the winter. The New York State Route 90 Scenic Byway stretches along the lake's eastern shore from Montezuma to Genoa, before turning eastward to its terminus in Homer.

In addition to the Cayuga Inlet at Ithaca, five tributaries at the southern end feed the lake. These are Cascadilla Creek, Fall Creek, Salmon Creek, Six-Mile Creek and Taughannock Creek. Cayuga Lake outlets into the Seneca and Cayuga Canal, which joins the northern ends of Seneca and Cayuga Lakes. This canal connects with the Erie Canal north of Seneca Falls. Lake Ontario can be accessed from Cayuga Lake via the Erie Canal, Cross Lake and the Oswego Canal.

Because of its low elevation, 384 feet above sea level, the lake has many marshes, particularly at the northern end, which extends into the Montezuma National Wildlife Refuge north of Seneca Falls. It was known as Gweh-u-gweh, "the lake at the mucky land", by the Cayuga Nation and "lake of the marshes" by the Mohawks.

Member Services
Agent Spotlight

Melissa Miller with RE/MAX IN MOTION in NY advertising on
A Team Of Cayuga Lake Specialists Working For You
Melissa Miller
313 N. Meadow St.
Ithaca, NY 14850

My Listings

Most Popular Rentals
Wanting to buy or sell a lake house or lake lot? Visit our other website... is a nationwide advertising service, used by real estate brokers, agents, realtors, and individuals to sell lake properties, vacation rentals, waterfront homes, lake lots, land, acreage, lake view properties, lakefront cabins, lakeside cottages, condos, log homes, riverfront, lake access, lake area homes, lake shore or any type of real estate for sale on public and private lakes, reservoirs and rivers all over the United States and Canada.
Members of
Last updated on
Copyright 2003-2018 © Use of this website constitutes acceptance of our
Terms of Use, Liability, Disclaimer Information